top of page

Should The Catholic Church Be A Hospital for Sinners and Not a Country Club for the Saints?

By Chris Heeb, Publisher | Midwest Faith Media |

In a world that often projects an image of perfection and exclusivity, the essence of the Catholic Church community stands apart. "Church is a hospital for sinners, not a country club for the saints" encapsulates a profound truth about the purpose and nature of a place of worship.

Does the above statement challenge the conventional perception that a church is solely for the righteous and perfect? Or does it paint a picture of inclusivity, compassion, and understanding? Maybe it echoes the belief that a church is not a place for those who have it all figured out but rather a sanctuary for individuals grappling with their imperfections and seeking solace, healing, and spiritual guidance.

Comparing a church to a hospital emphasizes its role as a place of healing. Just as a hospital welcomes individuals seeking physical healing regardless of their condition, the Catholic church welcomes all, irrespective of their spiritual state. It recognizes that everyone faces struggles and battles with inner conflicts, and seeks reconciliation, making the church a safe haven for all, regardless of their past or present.

On the contrary, the analogy of a country club for the saints highlights the danger of exclusivity and self-righteousness. Some in our faith have unfortunately “paid” the initiation fee and expect a certain standard of righteousness that tarnishes the image of our beloved Church. A country club may have stringent criteria for membership, reserved only for the elite or those deemed morally superior. However, a church should stand in stark contrast, embracing humility, empathy, and acceptance rather than fostering an atmosphere of elitism or judgment.

This statement serves as a reminder of the fundamental teachings of many faiths—love, compassion, forgiveness, and empathy. It challenges the notion of creating divisions based on perceived righteousness and instead encourages unity through shared experiences and a collective journey toward spiritual growth.

Ultimately, the essence of this statement lies in its call for a shift in perspective. One of the Bible verses that encapsulates the idea of a church as a nurturing ground for everyone, regardless of their background or status, is found in the Gospel of Matthew 11:28-30 (NIV):

"Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light."

This passage reflects Jesus's invitation to all, especially those burdened by life's challenges, to come to him for solace, guidance, and rest. It emphasizes the inclusive nature of Jesus's invitation, welcoming anyone who feels weary or troubled to find comfort and support in him.

It speaks to the essence of a church as a place where individuals, irrespective of their past struggles or present circumstances, can seek refuge and find acceptance in Jesus Christ. The emphasis on finding rest for weary souls and the promise of a lighter burden resonates with the idea that a church is a place where people can find support, understanding, and a path toward redemption through the teachings and love of Christ.

In a world marked by divisions, a church embodying the idea of a hospital for sinners extends an invitation—one that transcends boundaries and welcomes all seeking solace, healing, and a sense of belonging on their spiritual journey.

That should be the essence of our evangelization for the Catholic Church.


For a quarter of a century, Chris Heeb has been a pillar of the St. Louis community, embodying the role of a dedicated local business proprietor. He is passionately committed to his local community and promoting businesses that align with his mission. His Catholic faith is at the heart of his endeavors. As the owner of Midwest Faith Media LLC and the publisher of 2 Faith-based magazines in St. Louis, Chris channels his vibrant energy into inspiring families to reconnect with their faith. He encourages them to share their spiritual journey with friends and their wider neighborhood.

17 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page